MATTHEW PHIPPS SHIEL (1865-1947)
By Richard Shiell &
Dorothy Anderson. Revised Sept.
2006. Discussion welcome (hairman@mira.net)
Introduction.
The question of the origins of the West Indian novelist M. P. Shiel (Shiell)
has intrigued literary scholars for the past century. As A. Reynolds Morse said
in his book “Shiel
in Diverse Hands”-
“The connection of the merchant Matthew Dowdy Shiell
with the aggressive managerial Shiells has not yet been established. The
lineage question mark must be eliminated if we are to trace Shiel’s genetic
dynamism.”[1]
While the precise identity of the paternal grandparents of MPS has not yet been confirmed we have suggested some strong possibilities and have located many previously unsuspected sources of data for future research scholars.
Background
During the several years of research into our family history and the writing of Montserrat to Melbourne- The Story of a Shiell Family [2] we came across the story of the West Indian novelist M. P. Shiel. This was in a letter from a retired Montserrat physician and amateur historian, Dr Norman Griffin [3] was responding to a letter that Richard Shiell had written to the Montserrat newspaper in 1974, seeking information about his Shiell ancestors.
At the time, we felt there was some connection between M. P. Shiel (who was born Matthew Phipps Shiell), and our own family. We were both from the tiny Island of Montserrat in the British Leeward Islands (population never more than 10,000). In addition we both laid claim to the same spelling. There are some 60 or more ways of spelling this name when one includes all the Sh, Sch, ea, ie, ei, ee, l, ll, ld, and lds permutations. For reasons unknown, Matthew Phipps Shiell used “M.P. Shiel” in adulthood after he became established in London. [4]
Soon after the publication of our family history in 1984, Dorothy Anderson made a trip to Britain and conducted extensive research, mainly in the Public Records Office with the assistance of her friend and amateur researcher, June Bennett. Many interesting facts emerged about life on Montserrat and of the extended Shiell family.
What did
M.P. Shiell have to say about his ancestry?
Those familiar with the writings of Matthew Phipps Shiel, a novelist and writer of science fiction, know that he writes in a flamboyant, imaginative style with little regard to precise facts at times. They would not be surprised to find that his own version of his early life varies from one account to another. His father, Matthew Dowdy Shiell, was variously described as a trader, a ship owner and a Methodist lay preacher. We can confirm all three and now add “tailor” to this list.[5]
In his biographical writings MPS claims to be the only son after “eight or nine daughters” [6] but Shiel scholars note that he mentions only four by name in his writings. These were Augusta (“Gussy”, Ada Catherine, Sarah Jane (“Sally”) and Harriet Garry. The other sisters may have died young. He seldom mentions his mother except when writing about his two wives Lina and Lydia, both of whom he states resembled her in being olive skinned and dark haired.
He does not refer to his grandparents at all but mentions a doctor, Sir James Phipps Shiell, whom he claims to be his great-grandfather. He also claims to be of Irish descent and “descended from Kings”.[7] On another occasion around 1933, when asked directly about his racial origins, Shiel wrote –
“I am an Irish
Paddy- very mixed blood-Andalusian, Moorish-but perhaps no Negro”, …”Andalusian
girls have brown skin, dark brown hair, gaudy green eyes-deucedly pretty. One
of my sisters has jet black hair and brown eyes, a throw back perhaps to some
dim Negro while I, after a golden haired youth have nearly black hair but Irish
grey eyes”.[8]
Based on firmer grounds than the often mistaken beliefs of MPS, the authors of this essay have evidence to believe that the Shiell family of Montserrat are indeed of Irish descent, probably from a 17th century Westmeath family.[9]
We do not know what took the Shiells to the West Indies but what kept them there was probably the lucrative commerce in sugar, rum and slaves. This was boom trade of the 17th century and we have evidence that some of the Shiell family members were certainly involved. [10]
What did we make of all this?
Firstly working backwards from known facts we were aware that MPS was born on Montserrat on 20th July 1865. His parents were Matthew Dowdy Shiell and Priscilla Ann Shiell (nee Blake). [11]
The origins of Matthew Dowdy Shiell are not known for certain but we have the date of his death and burial, Jan 7th 1888 aged 63.[12] He was said to have been born on 18th Sept 1824 [13] and this would be consistent with the above. We know nothing of his early years but from 1850 onwards MDS appears in the historic record as an owner of small inter-island trading vessels and from 1852 as a merchant.[14] A previous occupation appears in at least one document where he is listed as “tailor from the Parish of St. Anthony”.[15]
Priscilla’s birth on April 13th 1828 was entered in the St Anthony’s Parish Register. The entry has the word “free” appended to it, which insinuates that the child is of black or coloured parentage but that the family was now free. Slaves were not liberated on Montserrat until 1834 so this was an important point in the registration of any child of free parents, six years before emancipation.
Matthew Phipps Shiel thus undoubtedly had at least one parent who was coloured and his father, Matthew Dowdy Shiell, may also have been of mixed blood, although this is not obvious from the only portrait known to exist.[16]
The only ancestor named by MPS was a doctor, Sir James Phipps
Shiell. We have not been able to
identify such an illustrious gentleman on Montserrat or elsewhere at this stage
but there was a Mr James Phipps Shiell on the island at the time of his
father’s conception. He was then
Customs Searcher and said by Dr Griffin to have been a witness at the wedding
of William Shiell in 1826.[17]
William was almost certainly his brother and the son of Queely Shiell, the
principal land and slave owner on Montserrat in the first half of the 19th
century. James Phipps Shiell was on the Assembly and at first Searcher and then
Comptroller of Customs until his death in 1834 [18].
His brother William Shiell was on the Legislative Council from 1808 and another
brother, John Shiell became Chief Justice of Antigua in 1943.[19]
James Phipps Shiell married Elizabeth Carey [20] and had two children Henry (1826) and Mary Ann (1830) about whom we know a great deal and who are the subjects of separate biographical papers by the authors. They both later migrated to Australia and Mary Ann has many descendants. [21] JPS may have had at least one illegitimate child before his marriage (as was very common on Montserrat both then and now). It is our contention that Matthew Dowdy Shiell may have been the product of such a union and we even have a possible candidate for his mother.
If JPS was the possible father, who could have been the mother of MDS?
We have discovered a document stating that on 4th Sept 1822 a child slave Priscilla, belonging to Mrs Sarah Dowdy was sold to Mr Dudley Semper at the Provost Marshall’s Sales.[22] A further document[23] shows that Priscilla was captured on the Dutch island of St Eustatius where she had been clandestinely brought by her mother, also a former slave of Mrs Dowdy.
Priscilla was returned to Montserrat on the sloop “Dasher” with some other runaway slaves in January 1824. Priscilla was identified by Customs Search Officer James Phipps Shiell.[24] It is our postulation that he may have taken a fancy to this young lady and a coupling (with or without her consent) may have occurred. MDS may have been the result and certainly the timing is right as Matthew Dowdy Shiell was born on 18th Sept 1824 – precisely 8 1/2 months later. The names of Dowdy and Shiell given to the child could be the crucial pointers to his origins.
Slaves and their offspring were not granted the privilege of a surname let alone a middle name but were required by law to assume a surname after emancipation. Whether Priscilla gave these names of “Dowdy” and “Shiell” to her son at birth or whether they were taken on after emancipation we have been unable to discover.
Mother and child would have been freed 10 years later in 1834 when all slaves were emancipated on Montserrat. Education for whites or blacks was not a priority on Montserrat at that time and the education of slaves on any of the sugar islands was either completely non-existent or pretty much confined to reading the scriptures. A favoured individual may have received some elementary lessons from a tutor with the other children of the household. As a valued personal slave of Mrs Dowdy, Priscilla may have acquired some domestic, literacy and social skills which she may have passed on to her son. The businessman and lay preacher Matthew Dowdy Shiell was obviously quite literate and many of his letters to his son in London have survived.[25]
We have no way of knowing whether this is the true course of events but if so, it may account for the vagueness and variability of MPS in writing about his origins. The possession of a father who was born a slave and illegitimate as well, was nothing to brag about in Victorian and Edwardian London. “Descended from Kings” certainly had a better “ring” to it and his earlier “coronation” on the island of Redonda in 1880 by the Reverend Dr. Semper, would have further imprinted such beliefs on his subconscious mind. (or was it by Dr Mitchinson – Phipps gives two accounts of this event).[26]
Alternate
paternity for Matthew Dowdy Shiell
Other possible fathers for Matthew Dowdy Shiell were Queely Shiell, William Shiell and John Shiell who were all alive and well on Montserrat in 1824. Their lives have been briefly documented by the present authors but no clues to the precise paternity of MDS have been found. It is almost certain that all those bearing the name of “Shiell” on Montserrat were related in some way - either as legitimate or illegitimate offspring. It is a very small island and everybody knows everybody else. [27] Shiell is a very specific spelling of a name that has, as we said earlier, over 60 alternates worldwide but only one on Montserrat. Bearers of the name Shiell are very particular in the spelling but this care is not shared by others who frequently have difficulty transcribing the name from one document to another.
MPS mentions a doctor Sir James Phipps Shiell as his great- grandfather but, as mentioned above, we can find no trace of this titled gentleman. On the other hand Mr James Phipps Shiell was a person of consequence on Montserrat where he was Collector of Customs, Registrar of Shipping and a member of the island Legislative Assembly. He was not a knight and was long dead at the time that Phipps was growing up but he had living descendents on Montserrat.[28]
A few words should be said here about the name “Phipps”. [29] The Phipps families were prominent in the West Indies, particularly on the island of St. Christopher where a William Shiell and Margaret Queely were married in 1756 and Queely Shiell was thought to have been born.[30] On the other hand MPS may have inherited the “Phipps” name through his mother, formerly Priscilla Anne Blake. Maria Charlotte Phipps of St Kitts married Sir Patrick Blake of Montserrat on 12th August 1789 but they had no children.[31] This does not preclude the possibility that Priscilla Anne or one of her parents had been sired by Sir Patrick and the Phipps name was commemorated.
There were many men by the name of Shiell holding important administrative positions around the Leeward Islands during Matthew Dowdy Shiell’s formative years. William was on the Legislative Council from 1809 and President between 1842 [32] and 1850. John was the Chief Justice of Antigua (1834-37).[33] Their father Queely Shiell, the principle landowner, was highly influential as Comptroller of Customs until he retired in 1827. He was Superannuated but did not seem to move to London until around 1843 and died in 1847, at the great age of 93 years.
Dr Norman Griffin presented a confident list of the legitimate male offspring of William (Appendix I) and in an 1842 petition to Lord Stanley, President William Shiell names William junior, born in 1826, as his oldest legitimate son.[34] Of course MDS may have been born to a mistress of William Shiell and if so, he had a busy year or two because we know for sure that he also had a son, named William, by the coloured woman Mary McNamara in 1823, before his marriage to Mary Cabey Semper.[35] It is certainly possible that he could have had a second child by this mistress 19 months later as Mary was still alive and paying rates in the town of Plymouth as late as 1848.[36] If so this would mean that MDS was a full brother of the authors’ ancestor. No mention of such a brother has ever been passed down to his descendents so we feel that it is extremely unlikely.
Queely Shiell was about 68 years of age when MDS was born, but as he went on to live to 93, he may have been quite healthy and sexually active for many years. [37] We must not forget John Shiell as a possible father. He was a barrister at law and seemed focused on social advancement but neither of these factors would preclude a dalliance with a coloured lass from a lower class. There is the strong possibility that he was the father of John N. Shiell, a coloured provision farmer who was born around 1820 and elected to the Montserrat Legislative Assembly in 1842.
Although we do not have his precise date of John’s marriage to his wife Elizabeth, it was probably around 1832 and we know that they subsequently had 4 daughters[38]. Brief biographies of both John Shiell and John N. Shiell have been prepared by the authors.[39]
Why was
MPS so ignorant of his family background?
In a letter to his sister Augusta in 1895, many years after he had left Montserrat for London, Phipps demonstrated this lack of family background knowledge quite clearly: “By the way I want to know the name of my father’s mother and also the maiden name of our old Granny. Would you write and let me know, and if you we get all we are; they fiz in our blood, and beat in our brain; it is they who stand yourself don’t know, try and find out for me. It is from the old folk, darling, that at my shoulder and dictate to me the very words I am now writing”.[40]
Although Shiells had been prominent on Montserrat for the first half of the 19th century, there were no important members of the family left on Montserrat when Matthew Phipps Shiell was growing up. His father MDS was a stern religious man, and he may not have cared to talk much about the “old days”. In those times, Montserrat had its own Assembly and Legislative Council and property owners from the planter class had ruled the island with fists of iron. Indeed any discussion on this subject with an inquisitive and intelligent boy like MPS would have required him to discuss his own humble origins as a Shiell from the “wrong side of the tracks”.
James Phipps Shiell had died in 1834 [41] and his only known legitimate son, Henry Shiell had probably been educated in England. He lived for a time back in Montserrat and married there in 1849 but had migrated to Australia in 1853 well before MPS was born.[42] William (senior) and his wife Mary had also died in 1853 [43] and although some of their children may have remained on Montserrat for a time, nothing is known of any of them except for his second son Henry, who will be discussed in the next section of this essay.
Other
Montserrat Shiells
William, the great-grandfather of the authors of this article, was the illegitimate son of William Shiell senior and the coloured shopkeeper Mary McNamara. He was born in 1823, became a master seaman and departed for England in 1853 on the ship “ Callender” and thence on to Australia on the barque “Gazelle” in the same year. [44]
The provision farmer, John N. Shiell was elected to the Assembly in 1842 [45] and may have still been alive in the time of MPS but life expectancy on Montserrat was short and this cannot be taken for granted.
Henry M. Shiell was alive on Montserrat until 1869.[46] He was married to Rosetta who was given a pension on her husband’s death and she died 17 years later in 1886.[47]
Moro Shiell in mentioned by MDS in a letter to his son in 1887.[48] We have no idea of the identity of this man.
A John Shiell is recorded as dying on Montserrat on 24th June 1899 aged 36. As he was born around 1863 he could have been either the son or grandson of John N. Shiell. He may have been the father of Arthur and Cornelius Shiell, fathers of the 20th century Shiell clan on Montserrat.[49]
As far as we can determine MPS never mentioned anything about Queely Shiell, the man who was almost certainly his great-grandfather. Queely had been the major land and slave owner on Montserrat with many sugar estates and 656 slaves by 1824.[50] Queely was Comptroller of Customs on Montserrat for many years. He was probably responsible for James Phipps Shiell obtaining the post of Searcher and then Assistant Comptroller[51] and finally Comptroller after Queely’s retirement in 1827.[52] He had died in London in 1847, 18 years before MPS was born.
Why Phipps would ignore such well-connected namesakes is a mystery. Perhaps his father did not speak of this branch of the family because of their association with slavery and the old plantation system. Surely others on Montserrat would have done so however, since they shared a common surname with this influential and possibly hated dynasty. He seldom mentions the evils and excesses of slavery in any of his writings although he appears to have been well aware of them.[53]
MPS mentions one West Indian family connection when he mentioned that
his sister Augusta married Samuel L. Horsford, a merchant and sugar agent on
St. Kitts. They had a son Cyril born 25th
January 1876, who obtained his medical degree in 1898, MD in 1902 and FRCS in
1903. He became a throat specialist at
24 Harley St. London and was Shiel’s personal physician.[54]
One can speculate that the local history of tiny Montserrat was of no interest to an academically minded Phipps in Britain in the 1880s and only the history of the Motherland,(Great Britain ) and Europe would have been considered important to him. This same skewed view of geography and history was apparent in Australia up until 40 years ago, so we must not be critical of MPS in this regard. A convict past was hidden and rarely transmitted to one’s descendants in Australia. Similarly, a slave ancestor would be concealed on Montserrat. In recent decades, both convict and slave ancestry have become badges of honour to be worn with pride.
Later
Life of the Author, Matthew Phipps Shiel.
The period up to 1900 has been well covered by Harold Billings in his excellent volume "M.P. Shiel: A Biography of His Early Years" [55] and a further volume on the later years is eagerly anticipated in the years ahead. In the meanwhile the reader of this essay will have to make do with the following summary of events.
The reader must be warned that a large number of purportedly biographical articles have been published about the elusive M. P. Shiel but most, including some written by Phipps himself, contain a good deal of inaccuracy. The most complete and reliable biographical information of the later years is held by author/ librarian Harold Billings of Austin, Texas and American lawyer/ publisher and long-time Shiel researcher, John D. Squires of Kettering, Ohio They have spent over 40 years reading and researching their subject.
For
a brief summary of the writer’s life and while we await Volume 2 of the life of
M. P. Shiel we enclose excerpts from a biographical sketch written by American
poet (and M. P. Shiel webmaster) Alan Gullette. It was revised in 2004
and
is approved by both Billings and Squires.
[56]
M. P. Shiel: Poet
and Prophet
"One of the most
remarkable minds and imaginations
of our time... a poet and a prophet..."
– Edward Shanks
After age 20, Shiel lived primarily in London and Paris, where,
according to E.F. Bleiler, he gravitated "toward the Bohemian fin-de-siècle extensions of
the Aesthetic Movement," which included Arthur Machen, Oscar
Wilde, and Robert Louis Stevenson. He also travelled throughout Europe
(particularly in Italy and Spain) before settling down in Horsham, in the
county of Sussex, England.
Shiel married twice. Arthur Machen attended his first wedding, in
1898, to Lina (Carolina) Garcia Gomez, who bore a daughter; Shiel left them in
Paris in 1903 and the fate of little Lina is uncertain.
In the winter of 1914-15 Shiel was inmate number 2225 in Wormwood Scrubs Prison. The charges are at present unknown but most possibly are related to debt. In the period between 1914-1919, Shiel had a daughter (and perhaps later a son) by Elizabeth Price.
His second marriage was to Esther Lydia Furley and lasted from
1919-1929, when they agreeably parted ways. According to Shiel, Lydia "resembled
both Lina and my mother."
Shiel listed the author of The Book of Job as "the greatest genius among writers
who ever lived" and "the greatest poet who ever lived." On
the same list, Shiel, never modest, included himself as "the best prose writer living. Phipps
said that his first published book, Prince
Zaleski (1895) had in it "more Poe than Job."
Dedicated to healthy living, Shiel listed mountaineering as one of
his hobbies. He jogged six miles a day into his seventies. He also practiced
some sort of deep-breathing exercises not unlike yogic pranayama and propounded them in essays
that accompanied his novels. He preferred to sleep during the day and work at
night, proclaiming, "I like the light of other suns better than
ours."
During his long life Shiel wrote
twenty-five novels, dozens of short stories, a small volume of verse, an essay
“Science,
Life and Literature” as well as some unpublished manuscripts. Many
of them are romantic mysteries and fast-paced adventures, several dealing with
world conquest. Others are distinctly supernatural or border on science fiction.
Most are interspersed with discourses on his philosophy and sociology of the
Overman. And most, regardless of subject matter, were written in Shiel's
patented poetic or "purple" prose.
In a review of the horror
collection Shapes in the Fire
(1896), Machen wrote "here is a wilder wonderland than Poe ever
dreamt of." He wrote to Shiel and praised him for achieving
what he himself had long attempted. The previous collection of stories Prince Zaleski (1895) – whose title
character is a rather macabre version of Poe's prototypical sleuth Auguste
Dupin – is described by Moskowitz as "Sherlock Homes in the House of Usher." Machen
addressed the likeness to Poe thus: "It is Poe, perhaps, but Poe with an unearthly
radiance." Not so impressed, Moskowitz refers to the style of
the early stories as "berserk Poe with all genius spent."
Shiel's The Purple Cloud
(1901) is a classic and probably his masterpiece. After Mary Shelley's The Last Man, it was perhaps the first
novel treatment of the "last man on earth" theme. H. G.
Wells called it "colossal... [a] brilliant novel." The
New York Post review declared him
to be "A
genius drunk with the hottest juices of our language."
In general, praise of Shiel's work flowed in from high quarters.
August Derleth dubbed him "the Grand Viscount of the Grotesque" and
applauded his "refulgently fanciful imagination and magical command of the
English language." Hugh Walpole reduced this to "a
flaming genius!" – adding, "He is not to be touched, because there is no
one else like him." E. M. Benson called his work "a
glorious excursion into the incredible." E. F. Bleiler's
summary:
"... his stories are a welter of stylistic sound effects, not to
everyone's taste." Other admirers included Dorothy L. Sayers,
Rebecca West, Dashiell Hammett, J. D. Priestley, Bertrand Russell, and L. P.
Hartley. As Moskowitz pointed out, he was "a writer's writer" – "His mad
literary rhythms, seemingly improvised, like a jazz artist's at a jam session,
were a bubbling fountain at which new techniques of phrasing could be
drunk."
Shiel spent over a decade of his last years on a New Testament
study entitled Jesus, which he
described as "a truer translation of Luke" from the original Greek
"in which is some detective work, proving for example, that the Apostle Paul
was the Lazarus who in his anti-Sadducee craze for resurrection stayed four
days in a tomb" and which set forth Shiel's own "religion
of science" – based on knowledge rather than hope ("ignorance").
He finished it five months before he died, but the manuscript remains
unpublished and as much as half of it is lost.
After 1934 or 1935, Shiel received a government pension; but his
last days in his Horsham cottage (which he named L'Abri, "The
Shelter") must have been meagre.
He died on February 17, 1947 at a hospital in Chichester, aged 81. At
his funeral a week later, Georgian poet and essayist Edward Shanks eulogized
Shiel as "a
poet and a prophet ... in the Old Testament manner."
In 1927, Paramount Pictures bought the film rights for The Purple Cloud; in the 1940s a dozen
screenplays were produced, but no film. Sol C. Siegel of MGM bought the rights
in 1957 and released The World, The Flesh,
and the Devil in 1959, starring Harry Belafonte, Inger Stevens and
Mel Ferrer. While entertaining (and controversial) in its own right, the film
falls far short of Shiel's magnificent, prodigal epic.
Though most of Shiel's writings are out of print and hard to find,
a few older editions are in print (e.g., the detective stories Prince Zaleski and Cummings King Monk from
Mycroft & Moran, 1977). The Purple Cloud
is in print in various editions (one may choose between the original,
serialized text of 1901 and the revised Gollancz edition of 1929. Most in-print
titles from various publishers and a posthumous edition of Shiel's final novel,
The New King, are available from J. D. S. Books.[57]
Once the present material on the West Indian Shiell clan is made known to
scholars it is possible that a new analysis of Shiel’s writings will reveal
coded references to the somewhat “shaded” past of some of his illustrious
Shiell relatives.
No thorough analysis of M. P. Shiel is
possible without first knowing of his early life on Montserrat. This in turn
requires an understanding of the historical, geographic, social and economic
forces that formed that society and then brought about its gradual decline.
Montserrat had passed from being a prosperous
island dominated by large sugar plantations, white managers and absentee
landlords in 1800 to a struggling society of small farmers and heavily indebted
and inefficiently worked plantations a half-century later. Sugar was no longer
“king”, freed slaves and their descendants made up the vast majority of the
population and degree of whiteness was of great importance in the social scheme
of things. Such was the circle into which Matthew Phipps Shiell was born in
1865.
APPENDICES
APPENDIX
I (a). Letter from Dr Norman Griffin to Dr Richard Shiell
25th August 1974
Richmond
Hill,
Montserrat, West Indies.
Dear Dr
Shiell,
I was
interested in reading your letter asking for information about your Montserrat
family published in the “Montserrat Mirror” of 16th instant. It
happens that William G. Shiell, who seems to have been the first on the scene
came out from Ireland at much the same time as my great-grandfather, John
Griffin who was born in Hutchin, Hertfordshire, England, in 1784 and married in
Montserrat in 1815.
William
G. Shiell was born in 1784 and married in Montserrat in 1826 to Mary Caby
Semper, daughter of Michael Joseph Semper.
This was in June 1826 and in August (2 months after) a son was born and
named William. We have no further
record of this son and it could be that he was your great-grandfather who
arrived in Australia as Mate on the brig Gazelle in 1853; maybe he ran away to
sea from school either in Montserrat or in England.
Of the
other children of Wm G. Shiell we have few records. Several seem to have died
as children; the family lived at The Grove or at Richmond (these two estates
probably even then run as one). Another son Henry was born in 1827; John Ross
was born in 1834, James Phipps in 1836, Queely in 1837, and the last, born in
1850, was also given the name of William but died at 5 months.
When
Queely was born William G Shiell was President of the Council of Montserrat; in
1848 he owned one estate called Morris’ in the South of Montserrat (small and
unimportant in comparison with many others), but was Attorney for about 10
others including a number shown on a list of Montserrat estates as owned by
Queely Shiell; he was also Executor, Lessee or Receiver in Chancery of another
14 estates. Presumably as President of the Council he had to divest himself of
some of his properties, giving his son the titles. Wm. G. Shiell died in 1853,
as did his wife Mary.
In
1849, Henry Shiell, Bachelor, married Mary Ann Wilcox, and we have reasons to
believe that he emigrated to Australia but have no idea as to whether he was in
touch with any of your family. In 1851, Thomas Masters Howes (of Yorkshire
England) who had come out from England in 1835 married a Mary Ann Shiell
(relationship not defined) and in 1879, 2 years after her husband died, she
went out to Australia with her 2 daughters, one of whom married a McMaster
whose son Shiell McMaster became a landowner and sheep farmer in New South
Wales. It is thought that Mary Ann was some relation of Henry’s and went out to
him in Australia.
Sorry
that this Aerogramme does not leave room for more. There is a long story about
another family named Shiel (with one l) starting with one Matthew Dowdye Shiel
who came out from Ireland and claimed descent from ancient kings of that
country. If you are interested I will write again.
Norman
Griffin M.D. (Mc Gill 1922)
APPENDIX I (b).
Letter from Dr Norman Griffin to Dr Richard Shiell
29th October 1974.
Richmond
Hill,
Montserrat,
West Indies.
Dear Dr
Shiell,
Thanks
for your letter of 17th September received on 25th. I
agree generally with some of your deductions from information available and in
particular about the likelihood that your William Shiell may have been the son
of the original William before his marriage to Mary Cabey Semper. Sorry I
cannot check on the 1823 dates as all records of the births before 1829 have
been lost.
As
regards the economic conditions of Montserrat in the 1840-1860 period, the
effects of emancipation of slavery which took place in 1834 was becoming felt
and the labour situation was difficult. Many estates were sold for indebtedness
or changed hands to newcomers at a fraction of the value a which they were
rated a few years earlier.
It
seems that Queely Shiell was the only one of the original William who like his
father was interested in agriculture; he followed his father as a Member of
Council and in charge of the Richmond and Grove Estates. It is suggested that the other brothers
followed some other calling, either in business or in Government, though we
have no records to confirm this assumption. Certainly none of them produced a
family in Montserrat.
The
family history would not be complete without the story of the Shiels (spelt with one “ l “) written up by
Charlesworth Ross six years ago in the Caribbean Quarterly, a publication of
the Extra Mural Department of the University of the West Indies. It begins with Matthew Dowdye Shiel who
claimed descent from the ancient Kings of Ireland and was living in Montserrat
in 1865 and trading between Montserrat and the neighboring islands. He had had
8 daughters before producing a son named Matthew Phipps Shiel born shortly
before that date. This son went to live
in England where he became a novelist and got to know many celebrities such as
Robert Louis Stephenson and Wilde; he was quite a linguist and once had a job
as interpreter to the International Congress of Hygiene and Demography.
Charlesworth
Ross, himself a West Indian, whom I know very well, went to visit him in his
later years when he was living in an Alms House near Horsham on a Civil List
Pension, and had a very interesting conversation with him. He afterwards wrote
up his story describing him as the first West Indian Novelist. He discovered
that his Grandmother was one of the Shiel sisters. Of his other sisters we know
little, except that the last surviving one was still alive in 1935 and living
in St. Kitts with a niece. She was in looks much as you describe other Shiell
descendants in Australia. It may well be that Matthew Dowdye Shiel was an
illegitimate son of the original William Shiell in Montserrat.
I hope
this is of interest to you
Sincerely,
Norman
Griffin.
APPENDIX
II. - A Possible Explanation for the
use of the Pen name “Shiel”
When Phipps became a published author he used the name “Shiel” rather than the name Shiell (which remained his legal name until the day he died some 40 years later). Many reasons can be put forward but I think that the most convincing comes from a personal communication from the Shiel scholar, Harold Billings, author of the definitive biography of the young M. P. Shiel. [58]
I think the reason for MPS using the name
Shiel on his writing was probably more simple and understandable than many have
suggested. The fact is that “Shiel” was the most prominent version of the name
extant in the literary/political world in the 1890s.
Richard Lalor Shiel was an
extremely well known man of letters and supporter of the Irish masses during
the period leading up to MPS's entry into the publishing world. I suspect
that his
was the spelling that editors and public expected, and it may be that Phipps
was perhaps glad to accept an early mistake in spelling and continue it, or
else glad again for an instance in which he might be identified with a famous
name.
Phipps
continued to use the "Shiell" spelling with his family until he
commenced being published, when even to them he used "Shiel. Until he
died, his legal name continued to be spelled "Shiell," so that if
ever there was a nom-de-plume it was only the shorter form of his legal name.
If one
looks at many of the authors in his literary circle, one can find MAJOR changes
in their names. "George Egerton," Henry Harland, Arthur Machen,
etc.
APPENDIX
III - Certificate dated 30th January 1824.
To the
Collector of Customs, Montserrat, in regard to the runaway child slave
Priscilla.
Montserrat,
30th January 1824.
I do
hereby Certify that Priscilla a Negroe Child Slave, the Property of Mrs Sarah
Dowdy, was sold by me at Marshals Sale and Purchased by Dudley Semper Esquire
on the 4th day of September 1822.
(signed)
Michl. Jos. Semper Dep. Pro.
Marshall
APPENDIX IV- Letter from the Governor of St Eustatius, regarding the return of several runaway slaves.
27th January 1824
Government House
St Eustatius.
Sir,
I have
delivered over to Captn Allers of the British Sloop “Dasher” four Slaves by
name Simon, Ino Matthews, Ned and William which it appears are the same of whom
Your honor gave me Notice under date the 24th July last and which
were at the time searched for in vain.
The
three first were concerned with nine other Slaves of this Colony in cutting out
of the Road of the Dutch Sloop “John and Anna” in the Night of the 30th
November last. They were pursued and fortunately taken by an Expedition, fitted
out by this Government, off Porto Rico, and brought back to this place where
they have been tried and punished according to our Laws.
William
did not go with them and returns without having been in anywise punished. Three
Slaves complain much of ill treatment and some of them bear evident marks of
the truth of their assertions.
There
is likewise aboard the “Dasher”a female Child, Slave to Mr. D. Semper of your
Island, whom it appears, had been clandestinely brought here by Her Mother, a
Slave formerly of Mrs Dowdy. She is sent up to her Master by his Attorney here.
Capt
Allers has my direction to report to Your Honor immediately on his arrival and
you will direct him farther how to proceed.
I have
the Honor to be
Sir, Your
Honor’s Most Obedient Servt
(signed)
J. M Saba
Post
Captain in His Netherland Majesty’s Navy
Governor of St Eustatius
APPENDIX
V . Certificate acknowledging the receipt of runaway slaves
from St Eustatius and signed by Edmund and Dudley Semper and James Phipps
Shiell.
Montserrat 30th January 1824
Mr
Dudley Semper, Edmond Semper Junior and James Phipps Shiell of the Island of
Montserrat. Do swear. That the Negroe Slaves just arrived in the Sloop Dasher
Ino D. Allers Master are truly and Bonafide the same Slaves as are described in
the several Certificates of Registration herewith produced. And that the said
Slaves did in the Month of July last 1823. Elope without leave, from this
Island taking with them the Boat the Property of a Mr John Brambles of this
Island. And upon receiving advice from a
Mr
Martine of the Island of St Eustatius informing us of the Arrest and Detention
of the said Slaves did Hire and dispatch the Aforesaid Sloop for the Purpose of bringing them to
this Island. So help me God.
(signed
and sworn)
Ed.
Semper
James
Phipps Shiell. (Attorney to the Representatives of James Neave, Deceased)
Dudley
Semper
APPENDIX VI. Petition from
William Shiell to Lord Stanley, Secretary of State for the Colonies, stating
his credentials and seeking assistance in procuring an Army Commission for his
oldest son.
Montserrat 7 May 1842
To the Right Honorable Lord Stanley
Her Majesty’s Principal Secretary of State for the Colonies
The Humble Memorial of William Shiell President of Her
Majesty’s Council for the Island of Montserrat
Humbly Sheweth,
That your Memorialist was appointed a Member of Her
Majesty’s Council, in the year 1808 and has continued to act in that capacity
ever since, being a period of thirty two years, that he succeeded in the month
of March 1840, upon the death of Mr President Hamilton, to the local government
of the Colony, which he administered until the Month of August 1841, without
deriving any Emolument from the Crown, or the Colony, to the satisfaction of
those who were placed in authority over him, and with advantage to the general
Interests of all classes of Her Majesty’s Subjects in the Island.
That he was superseded in the government of the Colony by Mr
Edward Dacres Baynes, the Provost Marshal of Dominica, by Mandamus under Her
Majesty’s Royal Sign Manual, and that he receives from the Crown five hundred
Pounds per annum, as the Officer Administering the government of the said
Colony.
That your Memorialist always anxious to support the dignity
of the Station, to which he had been involuntarily called to fill, entertained
at his own private expense, all public functionaries who visited the island in
their Official Capacities, during the period that he administered the
government of the Colony.
That your Memorialist is the Father of Eight children, three
of them receiving their Education in England, and three upon the point of being
sent there for as similar purpose, that he is desirous, having served her
Majesty’s Royal Predecessors, and Her most Gracious Majesty, with the strictest
fidelity, in his said capacity as a Member of Her Majesty’s Council, And as
President administering the Government of the Colony, during his term of
office, to obtain a Commission, in the Army for his Eldest Son William Shiell,
now in his Sixteenth Year, but that he is prevented from purchasing the same,
from a variety of concurring causes not necessary to be enumerated here,
without doing a manifest Injury to the Interests and claims of his other
children.
That your Memorialist therefore most humbly solicits your
Lordship to take the premises into your consideration, by using your
intercession in his behalf and recommending him in the proper quarter, as one
not undeserving of the Royal favor, with the view of procuring for his said Son
William Shiell a Commission in Her Majesty’s Army, in any Regiment of the line,
which may be deemed by those in Authority, most fitting and expedient to
appoint him.
And your Memorialist as in duty bound, will ever pray.
Wm. Shiel
APPENDIX VII. Notes on the Name Horsford.[59]
Samuel “Sammie” appears to have been a
natural son of one of the members of the wealthy Horsford family of Antigua,
where he was born. He is not included in the extensive “Pedigree of Horsford”
listed in Oliver’s book The History of Antigua. This strongly
suggests that he was from an illegitimate line. Sir Robert Marsh Horsford was
Chief Justice of Antigua at the time of Samuel Horsford’s birth, having taken
this office following the death of John Shiell, son of Queely Shiell, in 1847.
Whether Sir Robert had any relationship to Sammie is unknown.
Harold Billings has provided details of
the Horsford family in his biography of the early years of MPS. As he notes, the three sons of Sammie and
Augusta all attended Bedford Modern School, according to school records,
residing at "Matson House."
When Phipps died in 1847, neither Reginald nor Leo was mentioned in his
obituary, as were Cyril, Olive and Muriel, so it is likely that they were
deceased by that time. (One of the two
had in fact died by the time the family firm was sold in early 1929).
When Sammie died in 1913 The Times
of London provided a major obituary for him (December 20th, page
11c)
The Hon. Samuel L. Horsford, of St. Kitts, died in London
recently, aged 64. Mr Horsford, who was born in Antigua in 1849, received his
commercial training in that island and migrated to St. Kitts, where he
succeeded to the mercantile business of the late Captain J. H. H. Berkeley, and
became the agent of many of the principle sugar estates in the island. His
ability and public spirit were recognised by his appointment to be a member of
the Legislative Council of St. Kitts-Nevis and the Federal Council of the
Leeward Islands in 1894, and in 1911 he was nominated a member of the Executive
Council of the Federal Establishment, on which he sat until his death. He
proved a keen debater, and a strong advocate of economy in public affairs and
of representative government. A staunch
Freemason, he had filled all the offices in the Mount Olive Lodge of St Kitts,
and he was for many years a member of the West India Committee and the West
Indian Club in London. The Canadian Government appointed Mr Horseford
Commercial Agent for the Dominion of Canada and he represented St.Kitts-Nevis
at the conference at Ottawa in 1912, which resulted in the reciprocal trade
agreement between the Dominion of Canada and a majority of the British West
Indian Colonies. He was married to Miss
Sheil (sic), of Montserrat, who, with five children, one of whom has attained
the distinction as a throat specialist, survive him. Mr Horsford will be
greatly missed not only in St. Kitts, where he was a general favorite, but also
in this country.
The funeral service will be held at College Chapel, Swiss
Cottage, at 2 o’clock on Monday, and the interment will be at Kensal Green.
The company of SL Horsford & Co. Ltd
on St Kitts grew, in the 21st century, into one of the major
corporations in the West Indies. While
located on St Kitts, it handled a major series of business enterprises and
supported soccer teams and various cultural and civic activities. The Shiell
family interests in the firm were sold in 1929.
APPENDIX VIII -
Introductory Dedication in Shiel’s 1896 collection of short stories “Shapes in the Fire” to music
hall singer Beatrice Laws.[60]
To
Mistress Beatrice Laws
Dear
Beatrice,—The pieces of this inkling of a Book, which, with much longing, I
dedicate to you, were not all written in the same night, but separated in their
execution by intervals for eating and sleeping; and as you know me to be of at
least not less nervous vigour than your sweet self (for in Thee is not vigour
gobbled up in sweetness?), so you, too, red ruddes, should read them (in spite
of the sub-title), with like intervals, one by one, not gulp them like porridge
or a novel,—which, you know, are homogeneous, these being designedly
heterogeneous—or you will hardly, I think, get at what one meant to imply
(Easily, you know, in the crash of the orchestra, do the light flute-notes lose
themselves on the tired ear: a fact which seems to indicate that works of art,
especially such as pretend to be more or less musical should be not only pretty
short, but separately imbibed; so that the Concert, for one thing, is wrong;
and with it, the book, such as this, of short detached pieces, which is a
literary Concert; only that here, you have it in your option to extend your
concert into as many nights as there are pieces; and your concert-giver, too,
hath it more in his dominion what piece shall company with what, and what shall
be the precise complexity and information of the whole.) Well, but to maintain
the dear fiction of the Winter’s Night, I will say this (epistolary—and not as
they write big in the volume of the Books, lest you pout): that the curtain
having risen, I will present you first a diary-extract of a poor friend now
dead; then a little morne drama which I have encountered in the chronicle of
one Aventin von Tottenweis; and next a rather dark experience of my own in the
dim Northern seas, which, in dream, yet revisits me. Then will be a short
interlude for cigarettes, ices, and whispy-lispy, during which will be rendered
a piece just splashed down anyway, for a male reader or two, and in some
places dull (to you I mean) and in others pretty cheap,—this, however, being a
day of cheap things, sweetmeat; you yourself, perhaps, not so over-dear, and
only over-dear to the beglamoured eyes of male-made me. This, then, you should
skip (recalcitrant roe that thou art on the Mountains of Endeavour!) Go out on
the verandah, pig’s-eye, and there heave, the open secret of that torse my soul
remembers to the chaste down-look of Dian’s astonished eye-glass, and the
schwärmerei of the winking Stars. But soon, at about midnight, return; for now,
to the tinkle of a silver bell, will unfold itself the life-history, very well
translated by me from the original, of a poor man of Hindustan, not, I verily
believe, unloved of the gods, but loved, you perceive, in their peculiar
fashion: those people (as the late Mr. Froude uncommonly said to the dying
Carlyle) probably having reasons for their carryings-on, of which we cannot
even dream. And truly, dear, this is marvellous in our eyes, or at least in
mine. Well, but now, just as that dark Daphne with the gems entangled in her
hair turns paling in flight from the red rape of day, I shall (spiritualest
wine coming last, you know, as at that Marriage) once more introduce myself in
character this time of lover, and tell how I wooed one of the ladies of my
heart at world-illustrious Phorfor. Immediately whereupon, Beloved, shall the
Day break, and the Shadows flee away.—Yours, pour toujours et une Nuit
d’Hiver! THE AUTHOR
APPENDIX IX.
Known partners and offspring of Matthew Phipps Shiel.[61]
1. “Mary” is pregnant to Phipps in 1894 but we do not know Mary’s surname or what became of her and the baby who would have been born mid-1895.
2. Ella D’Arcy, short story writer and an Editor for publisher John Lane, may have had an affair with Phipps around 1895.
3. 1895-98. A possible brief liaison with the French maid of fellow-author Arthur Machen. He described her seduction of him in a letter to Gawsworth in 1933 but knowing Phipp’s love of fantasy this may have been wishful thinking.
4. 1896. In a letter to his sister Augusta, Phipps announces that he is “engaged to be married” to a singer at Queen’s Hall, a London music hall. He does not name this lady in the letter but she may have been the singer Beatrice Laws to whom he dedicates his 1896 collection of short stories “Shapes in the Fire”[62]. This dedication is amazingly poetic and worth reading, so please see Appendix VIII above. We do not know what happened to this relationship but after reading the letter and the book Beatrice may have come to the conclusion that Phipps inhabited a different planet and was not suitable marriage material. Alternativ